I don't disagree with you guys, but I think those definitions really apply to adulthood in general and not just to "manliness." In this day and age, regardless of gender, I think it's every adult's responsibility to help support his/her family and not whine or complain about it. I'm not sure I know how to define "manliness" as opposed to "womanliness," though. I guess it deals with being what you consider masculine. For some people, maybe that does mean having facial hair. Maybe for others it means being muscular or being a good hunter or fisherman.